E Contrario

French dinner for 3

Jul 2nd, 2007 by Tian

dinner final
Najib doesn’t want to be reminded with this romantic event

Najib Razak again denied he was acquainted with Altantuya. Last Friday 29 June, Burmaa Oyunchimeg testified in court that she had seen a photo of Najib and Abdul Razak Baginda having dinner with her cousin Altantuya.

Najib has repeatedly denied any knowledge of Altantuya during campaign of the recent Ijok By-election. Is our deputy prime minister so forgetful that he could not recall the murdered Mongolian lady.

Najib has a lot of explanations to do. Najib can not evade answering many questions pertaining his close connection with Razak Baginda.

What is also missing from the trial is link of the accused with the purchase of French submarines.

The public has the right to know who Altantuya was working. Was she officially hired by Razak Baginda (or the Ministry of Defence?) on the submarine deal?

Anwar Ibraham held a press conference at 15:00hr on the same Friday afternoon. He called on Najib to be investigated.

The director general of Immigration must also be called to explain why the record of entry of Altantuya and her companions could be erased. Was it done by his subordinates without his knowledge? Or he was instructed by his superiors?

Posted in Altantuya case, Current Issues, Human Rights | 254 Comments

254 Responses to “French dinner for 3”

on 03 Jul 2007 at 2:15 pm1drMpower

mr chua,

i think u are smart enough to not to display a superimpose picture and to nick one or two cheap shots to Datuk Najib.
but i understand that you need to pull all the shots you have at your disposal for your political sake.
atleast, just put there ‘this is a superimposed image’

cheap shots
on 03 Jul 2007 at 2:22 pm2AZHAR

gambar ni palsu, mana mungkin Najib pakai kot, depan dia pun tak de air, kena cari gambar asli baru betul.
gambar ni tak perlu taruk la..
menurunkan saham je…
on 03 Jul 2007 at 2:26 pm3AZHAR

Berpolitik biar betul, anta tu Ketua Penerangan jaga imej sikit,
tengok sekali pun tahu , itu gambar palsu,….
jangan taruh ..
jatuh saham Keadilan je…
bye…bye
on 03 Jul 2007 at 2:58 pm4Anonymous

bro

the photo looks very superimposed. are you sure your sources is correct?

this can be libel if you are wrong.

but if you are right, a DPM should step down, IMMEDIATELY!
on 03 Jul 2007 at 3:13 pm5mudin001

looks like a superimposed image to me!
on 03 Jul 2007 at 3:59 pm6Anonymous

please look at the malaysia today website commentors comments on your photo.
do you have a point for this ?
i hope you got the real photo somewhere.
that picture you posted will be very very disadvantage to you.

Justice for Altantuya!
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:04 pm7Gambar Najib, Razak dan Altantuya « jiwo kelate

[...] Gambar oleh “French Dinner for 3“. [...]
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:08 pm8thomas

This is not Altantuya, this is a Korean actress photo, SMART !
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:17 pm9jelas.info » M’sia Today & Tian Chua - No sense of humour, or malicious intent?

[...] all people, I would expect M’sia Today to have a sense of humour. Trying to accuse Tian Chua of passing the picture below off as something real is insanely [...]
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:20 pm10NAzmi

heheheheheh gambo tipuuuuuu
tipu gilaaaaaaaaaaa
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:30 pm11tun

bro it’s a superimposed. anway nice try bro.. heh
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:41 pm12Mad Malaysian Pig

This must be a joke right?
The proportion of that middle old fart is completely wrong. The lighting on the slut’s face on the left seem to come from the top, and it’s way brigther than anything else in the room and it doesn’t fit the lighting falling on her ’so-called’ arm. The brightness of the face was desperately being dimmed down to fit the scheme and failed terribly. And the slut has double chin to the max~~~~!!!

The old Fart in the middle has no body, as he looked like a flat piece of cut out cardboard used for advertisement, probably for viagra as he seemed like he needed one.
on 03 Jul 2007 at 4:56 pm13Shagadelica » Blog Archive » The Najib-Razak-Altantuya incriminating photo

[...] Tian Chua via Malaysia Today has published a photo that purportedly shows Najib sitting at a table with Razak [...]
on 03 Jul 2007 at 5:25 pm14BungkusMokhtar

Tian CHua,

We have so much hope on opposition. And opposition is showing desperation in their attempt to attack BN.

What MAN!
on 03 Jul 2007 at 6:13 pm15Concerned

This is clearly a fake. You don’t need to be a photoshop genius to recognise this is a fake. Ask yourself, the DPM is a tall man. So where are his legs and feet? Look at the chair behind him. If he were sitting so low, you would be able to see the side of the chair. And why is he staring in a completely different direction to the other 2 in the picture?
More and more, consumers are searching for personal opinions because they donâ€™t trust marketing messages any more. Bloggers are increasingly influential and have a critical role to play in the post mass economy digital era.
But when they post such blatantly fake images the general public will lose faith, reduce their trust in the bloggers and the bloggers potentially influential role eroded.
The prosecution has a strong case. Don’t try to influence the course of justice by posting such rubbish.
on 03 Jul 2007 at 6:19 pm16Concerned

here’s the link to the original pic of najib taken at the world economic forum
http://k53.pbase.com/g4/73/577473/2/61935184.qZDejLWS.jpg
on 03 Jul 2007 at 10:24 pm17The Malaysian Blogosphere » Blog Archive » Jeff Ooi: Likely a fake

[...] light in diverse conditions to portray them in very telling stories, I tend to believe that that threesome picture is a [...]
on 03 Jul 2007 at 10:53 pm18commentlah

i think dun take the caption literally…
on 03 Jul 2007 at 11:04 pm19kerrylah

laa..memang gambar ni tak betul pun..
dan tian purposely letak gambar ni..adalah maksud tersirat tu..
nak faham..kena baca dari sudut politik yg tersirat..

tian nak gambarkan beginilah kot gambar yang mungkin ada..
budak kecik pun tak percaya ni gambar betull..
apalah korang ni..
on 03 Jul 2007 at 11:36 pm20SuperGenius

all you guys are dumb f**ks. didn’t you all get the jokes??
on 03 Jul 2007 at 11:39 pm21SuperGenius

didn’t you all notice that even atlantuya face is superimposed?? or are you guys too smart to notice… and mr tian chua didn’t notice? doh..
on 03 Jul 2007 at 11:54 pm22encik fakap

although the #fakap group is known by its fakapness, we aint doing this cheap fakaping trick with Photoshop lol. I wonder who really bought this picture… maybe somebody as gullible as you are, wtf!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 12:31 am23Rawnsley

There is no doubt that the photo is a fake - even Tian Chua would acknowledge that and also know that anyone with common sense can figure that out. (But we live in a country with very little of that - if not Tengku Razaleigh who was felled with the pix of a cross on his Kadazan headgear would have been PM)

Why Tian indulges himself so stupidly is a mystery. Now when the real picture comes out - I’m sure Tian Chua’s doctored pix will be used to cause confusion and will get airtime in order to show that it was the work of the enemy and blur what might actually be the truth.

Stupid Boy Tian Chua ! Don’t be so amateurish . You once ran for parliament with good intentions !

Karpal has got the pix and it will come out in time. You have just spoilt his well-laid gambit !!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 2:28 am24al

agreeing with rawnsley. joke or not, this was a horrible stunt to pull. news travels fast on the net and considering the hype behind the picture, people will end up spreading the news that the picture is a fake and that will just end up in favor of the accused. you can’t be that desperate for the hits can you?
on 04 Jul 2007 at 2:35 am25Well done, Tian Chua. « O.B.E.

[...] the real Mccoy ‘swiped’ from T.C.s [...]
on 04 Jul 2007 at 7:58 am26ntpalsu

Maaf! kalau begini cara PKR mencari publisiti, PKR tidak ada kredibiliti, amat memalukan. Rakyat zaman IT tidak mudah ditipu. Gambar French dinner for 3 adalah PALSU! rendahnya moral PKR, Tak takut dosa ke! menyebar fitnah. Kalau hendak jadi parti yg credible biarlah bijak, guna akal dan logik pada fikiran rakyat. Tian Chua ada niat lain kot! cuba menjatuhkan pemimpin yang berwibawa berjasa dan berjuang untuk rakyat. Itulah motifnya. Pergi jahanam dengan Tian Chua!!!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 9:19 am27Gurindam Jiwa

At least make it a good fake laa.
This is injustice to those expert Photoshop gurus out there.
May be should be posted under humor. No?
on 04 Jul 2007 at 9:50 am28frankie

This is so sick, your credibility by posting this fake pic has gone down to the drain. Either you are so stupid with no brain or you are just so misguided and ill intention, either way you have lost my respect. Grow up!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 9:52 am29TskTskTsk

The author of this article has shamed himself.

I can clearly see the 3 images of the 3 people are superimposed!

What a moron…

If you did posted this yourself.. You are a moron and not fit to even fight for a place in the parliament.

However, there is another posibility that someone from BN may have hacked into this website and posted the image and article. I hope this is the case, if not Tian Chua YOU ARE A MORON!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 10:22 am30QuickSand

Why is the so-called Altantuya’s head int this picture looks so weird…like it is loose or something? You miss-positioned the head. Hey…i can make a superimposed of those people even better than this! Jgn la buat mcm ni bro…malu kat orang je. Sudahlah keADILan sdg dilanda krisis, tambah pulak benda2 mcm ni…lagilah jatuh maruah dan nama keADILan…i WANT you to take out this photo or AT LEAST put a remark that this photo is just a superimposed or something like “Just my imagination”…mannnn….i cant believe this!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 10:57 am31usinramlee

tahniah & congrat kepada yang mencuba menyuper imposekan gambar ni.. kena banyak belajor lagi, tak cukup real.. tqvm
on 04 Jul 2007 at 11:30 am32semuaok

Tian Chua, you have been calling a lot of others to resign, If you had any character at all, you should resign immediately and offer a true apology, not the lukewarm and self-serving type. Be a man
on 04 Jul 2007 at 1:51 pm33Lady

This is FAKE.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 2:46 pm34James

You put yourself forward for propriety and justice and end up looking dishonest and distasteful.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 4:07 pm35Xiao Zhen

round table, please.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 4:18 pm36jararaca

Aiyo..of course, it is fake. DPM should come out and defend himself.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 4:31 pm37bzz

Hahahahaha….

You should buy ‘Adobe Photoshop Superimposed for DUMBASS’

Muhahahahaha….
on 04 Jul 2007 at 5:18 pm38ewoon

Dear TC,
The last person i expect to pull a stunt like this is you. What were you thinking?

i think a retraction is in order.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:04 pm39monsterball

Tian Chua…You are a sick man to have a doctored photo out.
What do you gain by doing this bad low down sick joke on Najib?
Furthermore..it involves a dead person…not a love affair.
Where is your sense of proportions and responsibilities?
I wonder does Anwar approve of your bad conduct.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:05 pm40monsterball

hahahahaha…MY COMMENTS UNDER MODERATION.
ARE YOU NUTS????

(No intension to censor your comment, moderation on my blog is only to filter spam and inflammatory remarks –cheers, Tian)
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:11 pm41Niuku

Hi all Bro & Sis,

No need to over react on this picture . For anyone with a sense of humour, after seeing the picture knows that this picture is created by a rather creative artist.

Did anyone ever ask this:- Did Tian Chua or anyone else in this world claim that this picture is real ?

Get real.. It appears to me that deep inside many of us, many are still die hard supporters of the other side. Think about that.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:23 pm42oster

Sir,

May I recommend that, if you want to put up a picture as a PARODY, you must make it extremely overblown so as to avoid people actually assuming you are serious.

However, if this wasn’t parody, you’ve got lotsa explaining to do.

cheers
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:25 pm43monsterball

Since you want to moderate me…I may as well tell you…that you are a real selfish idiot..doing thing only with ulterior motives to glorify yourself. All the time I have so much compassionate feelings for you…seeing you suffer to try put out a message like a one man human rights show…..shirt torn and got arrested.
In actual fact…you are trying to get a party attention and you have succeeded now with Keadilan…..which is infect still insignificant with one rep in the parliament. So don’t get swell headed yet.
With your low down cheap scat trick on Najib….you have actually spoil your own reputations. Go stand for election…and see how many votes you can get.
One of your very close friend…a blogger told me you are shit. I don’t believe it…until now.
Applying moderation on me shows what a sickening hypocrite you are…. showing…fighting for freedom…yet you moderate truthful message. You simply cannot accept truths about yourself…how on earth you can understand the needs and wants of the people…if you really win seat in next election?
on 04 Jul 2007 at 6:34 pm44monsterball

By the way…I am no pro BN nor UMNO. Infect I have high hopes on Keadilan to provide better democracy in our country….but with guys like you…we may a well re-elect all the half past six. At least we know what they are.
If ever Keadilan want to get more votes..guys like you is good for carrying banners….not a candidate for election….dream on Tian Chua. MODERATION ON ME……You can put out false photos and you moderate truthful remarks.? Grow up child!!
on 04 Jul 2007 at 7:47 pm45KEADILAN

yea, all of us know this photo is ‘fake’ , but the real 1 is hiden in the corner of this world or spil by some 1, i hope the real photo mentioned by the witness can appear as soonest as possible. But let us think, y some 1 try to lie us ? is it any benifit ? TIPU Semua orang tapi tak dapat TIPU sendiri dan TUHAN. harap harap dia ni bukan penipu. Mari kita samasama menahan KEADILAN KITA
on 04 Jul 2007 at 7:58 pm46jest

Some of you are really stupid. Read between the lines!

There was nothing that suggest this photo is of Altantunya
on 04 Jul 2007 at 7:59 pm47Eder

Dear Tianchua,
You posted a picture which is being doctored. If you were a journalist in the western country , you will be sacked immediately

This accusation is related to a high profile criminal trail. Could you imagine someone who may be wrong jailed by you “fact”
on 04 Jul 2007 at 8:47 pm48leong

actually we need to give support to the opposition.
why?ohk.like all of us knows barisan sure win.but then we need opposition to control 20% of the country or more.so that opposition can speak for us.i am here to tell this is because do all malaysian citizen know my sister got robbed and now she is still in coma.
i wrote this with much tears flowing.where is the justice?me and my family fill up the forms to the headquarters but nothing have being done until today.malaysia,where is the justice?where is the fairness in this country.we pay tax every month.we pay tax every month NOT TO LET OUR CHILDREN OR FAMILY MEMBERS GET RAPE!!GET ROBBED!!!we pay TAX every month not to tell the goverment to increase the price of petrol!!why are the BARISAN MP so rich?cant they give some money to the rakyat or helped the poors..i am sad seeing malay,chinese and indian beggers begging for money.asking for food.small girl at the age of 12 years old got to beg for food.why cant the goverment give them some money.even rm2 per day can make them survive..!!!!!please goverment.we sincerely beg you.we have trust you for years and years.but i am so sorry.there is no more trust in the goverment from me.we need opposition to hold up as many seats as posisble so barisan will have to work harder.lastly i hope all leaders can work hard for the people..like what dr anwar ibrahim said..nak kaya biar semua kaya..nak miskin biar semua miskin..so all malaysian,please let barisan lose a few seats so they can wake up and work hard for the people.
vote for opposition!check and balance
written by,
LEONG
on 04 Jul 2007 at 10:49 pm49Bonkers

Good job for dissolving my faith in the opposition. Shows that the opposition can be just as twisted as BN. Brainless. Don’t resolve to cheap shots and don’t think people are as stupid as you think they are.
on 04 Jul 2007 at 11:45 pm50stopa

Wei…… take it down that stupid SUPER IMPOSE image…. even the stupid idiot people can judge….. THE PICTURE ARE FAKE….

Common Tian.. its not right to do that… where’s your ethic.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 1:32 am51naguib

pathetic lies
on 05 Jul 2007 at 1:50 am52fakela

oh my god! even a dog can know that’s so damn fake…good one….
on 05 Jul 2007 at 2:27 am53John

Oh.. My God.. Please.. Don’t mempersiasuikan all of the support here. That Picture sure look like Lousy “PHOTOSHOP” + ED, and it is simple CUT and PATSE…. Please tell me that is joke
on 05 Jul 2007 at 2:45 am54Gatsby

Mr Tian Chua

It is a sad day when the very people you are trying to reach not only do not understand you, but refuses to understand you. It is indeed a very eviscerating feeling, but know that as you persevere, so shall one day the people be illuminated. Take the ‘uproar’ not at heart, but in wisdom.

Lawan tetap lawan.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 6:34 am55E Contrario » Blog Archive » The truth as one sees

[...] running for a year now, and no writing has drawn so much debate and attention as my recent post â€œFrench dinner for 3â€. It is the most viewed post of my blog. But unfortunately it is probably the least [...]
on 05 Jul 2007 at 6:53 am56monsterball

See everyone is saying you did the wrong thing. You should write an open apology to Najib in papers.
Glad you withdrew all your moderations on me.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 7:46 am57nonameneeded

hey…its a fake….if someone can a make someone head to another person naked body…of course their can make this type of picture…but still its a fake…..
on 05 Jul 2007 at 9:27 am58prophotoshop

Hi,

You are not so pro lah.. ur techniques in doing this superimposed thing is not good and convincing. If there is a scale of 10, I wud give u 2/10. U need to learn and practice more on how to use DTP software. Low quality techniques.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 9:41 am59stupid

you have made the word ’stupidity’ much more meaningful.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 11:31 am60Pist Off With The Case

Tian Chua. Now I found this picture I wanted to see!!!! Well done. Guys. Tian Chua is a lawyer and he knows what he is doing. Firstly, if you look at the photo, there is a caption under it. What does it say ?

My interpretations is that Tian Chua is trying to say,
“Najib doesnâ€™t want to be reminded with this romantic event”. As we know, a picture paints a thousand words. So, you have to read the caption and the picture together. In full sentence, it merely means, Najid does not want to be reminded of the event where Altantuya’s cousin mentioned that he was having dinner with Altantuya.

Well done Tian Chua. Well done.

You see, there is no point Tian Chua is gonna apologise.

I really feel happy when this photo is displayed (legally). Now BN would have a taste of how the MPs of the opposition feel when their photos were superimposed into sexual compromising positions.

Great WORK!
on 05 Jul 2007 at 12:11 pm61ray c,BKK

Good try..bro.Whether is fake or real,it doesnt matter.God knows!!
on 05 Jul 2007 at 1:27 pm62valisca

People should really lighten up. I don’t know you Mr. moderator/Photoshop-er, but I am (still) very amused by the photo. FINALLY! The BN MPs can taste their own medicine! After all they’ve done to the opposition leaders, from sexist and “BODOH!” comments to lying through their teeth to the rakyat about the falling apart buildings, not so SMART tunnel, the increasing crime rates and the list goes on… this picture is NOTHING compared to the list of atrocities this government has imposed upon us.
Come on citizens of the “other truth”.. why can’t we let the opposition have their fun sometimes? Especially since we know that there is the existence of that 1 original photo.. and until those implicated come clean (and produce photo), they must understand being subjected to photoshopped-photos is part of the deal….
on 05 Jul 2007 at 2:19 pm63golden

Hi man,

We all read newspaper and understand the DPM, Razak Baginda, Altantuya took photo together… but why no people show real pictures in internet???? real one man

Can somebody show the picture to us…. please…..

TQ
on 05 Jul 2007 at 2:46 pm64proncontra

a fake..as fake as the man who publish this photo. Cheap-jack surely!!!
on 05 Jul 2007 at 3:00 pm65Objective

Simply intelligent. You have achieved the objective of it and people who are pursuing the truth.
on 05 Jul 2007 at 3:40 pm66squeak. speak. roar. | Fake plastic idiots.

[...] those who so intelligently pointed out that the famous dinner for three image found at politician’s X’s blog is a fake, YOU PEOPLE ARE [...]
on 05 Jul 2007 at 5:59 pm67jovis

Frankly speaking, that picture might bring problems to you…

Beside that, there is only God will know about what was really happen to the victim. In my point of view, I do agree that the point of the topic is not about the photo, but it’s about to look for the real facts!

And, one more important thing I got to mention is, (all of us) please respect to the victim, even she is not Malaysian, but she is a human just like you and me. Since she is already dead, can we pay respect to her (and her family..) and not calling her as ’slut’ (I saw someone written as it in the 12th reply…)? I’m sure that you also will not like people to call you ’slut’ or ‘dog’ after you died, right?

Justice: Whoever guilty will have to payback sometimes later. But in fact, how strong will Malaysia to prove this to the world (and God)?
on 05 Jul 2007 at 6:04 pm68Sack him

PKR leaders please sack this moron. Election is so near and you cannot afford to have this type of people
on 05 Jul 2007 at 7:49 pm69Kelvin Ng

Dear TC,

Where is my earlier comments? Deleted??
on 05 Jul 2007 at 7:50 pm70Freedom

Tian Chua Please Lift the photo you know is not the real picture.. this should not be the way KeADILan Doing things..it will kill KeADILAN image only and it not going to bring any good to the party..pathetic lies
on 05 Jul 2007 at 7:54 pm71arifabdull

she wasn’t Althantuya. anyone saw her or Abdul Razak Baginda in this picture? nothing wrong with the picture, liao.

Bravo, Tian!
on 05 Jul 2007 at 8:06 pm72Kelvin Ng

Perphaps my comments were inadvertently deleted. Reproduced herebelow my comment on 3/7/2007.

Dear Tian Chua,

It is my view that posting a doctored photo of the trio is irresponsible and can be construed as disrespect to the deceased regardless of the point you intended to raise or to be put across. I am dissapointed!

I hope you will have the courage, intergrity and the decency to tender an apology to the deceased, her family and even to both razak and najib. (Although I am not a supporter of Najib but any person doesn’t deserve such a move from you) Respect his human right as you have constantly preaches. Najib has a right not to be manipulated in such a degrading manner. If you have the real picture, then by all means post it but don’t resort to such uncalled for tactics! You are implicating najib and razak based on a pice of doctored evidence. I am not sure whether such act on your part tantamounts so subjudice in view of the on going trial.

Please..I implore you to tender an unreserved apology to all to salvage your credibility as a sincere opposition member/NGO.

Thanks
on 05 Jul 2007 at 10:06 pm73arifabdull

kelvin said “It is my view that posting a doctored photo of the trio is irresponsible and can be construed as disrespect to the deceased regardless of the point you intended to raise or to be put across.”

which deceased, huh?!

do u means that the mystery women in that picture also gone, pass away? how do u know?
on 05 Jul 2007 at 11:20 pm74 Tian Chua’s mind games by reduced and recycled

[...] Controversial picture, isn’t it? DPM Najib flanked by his right hand man on his left (how would you read that, Tian Chua?) and the super-imposed face of a false Altantuya on his right. In one picture, you have an RPK-esque rumour, a case of mistaken identity (and whose, and the substance of which is what, I wonder?) and the scandal of an unanswered question. [...]
on 05 Jul 2007 at 11:37 pm75tikustebu

nampak sangat super imposenya gambar najib & muka altantuya tu… kalau nak impose pun, cari le yg lebih real….
on 06 Jul 2007 at 2:13 am76Photoshop Politik Lindungi Pembunuh Sebenar « Bloginie

[...] (sesetengah orang mendakwa “menyalahgunakan”) teknik Photoshop ini untuk menghasilkan gambar Timbalan Perdana Menteri Najib makan malam bersama Abdul Razak Baginda dan seorang model wanita [...]
on 06 Jul 2007 at 3:01 am77dissapointed

when you are in politics the nation is in your hand. you dont do it just for fun. if you like art, be an artist.. dont fool around with peoples life and future.

this doctored picture has serious implication on PKR credibility. who would vote for a party with an information chief who lies in public and refuse even to apologise and retract the lies.
on 06 Jul 2007 at 6:52 am78Kelvin Ng

Dear TC,

I now must apologise for my error. My earlier posting was not deleted. It was in reply to your post “Humor” rather than “French Dinner for 3″.

I hereby tender my most sincere and unreserved apology to you for the error.

In the meanwhile, i would like to know whether you would tender an unreserved apology as well to all in particular the deceased’s family for the doctored image issue.

Thank you.
on 06 Jul 2007 at 8:14 am79Pist Off With The Case

WELL DONE TIAN CHUA. Read ( http://www.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2007/7/6/nation/18228994&sec=nation - Tian Chua: I wonâ€™t apologise - The Star)

Tian Chua, even if your mouth is stuffed with difficult-to-obtained-and-approved-by-high-ranking-officials-only C4 explosives (SIMILAR TO THE ONES THAT BLEW UP ALTANTUYA), don’t ever apologise.

Somebody may have used C4 to blow up Altantuya out of proportion but you my friend, you merely used your creative fantasy work of art to blow those BN to pieces (not literally)
on 06 Jul 2007 at 8:23 am80kaz

how unprofessional
on 06 Jul 2007 at 11:51 am81Altantuya Murder Trial - So who did it? · The Malaysian Billboard

[...] also carried a report on Tian Chua’s blog where he posted a picture entitled French Dinner for 3. I found it amusing, read Tian Chua’s blog and I believe you will [...]
on 06 Jul 2007 at 11:58 am82parti kebodohan rakyat

no wonder PKR never wins anything
too stupid and too free to do all these stupid things
on 06 Jul 2007 at 1:17 pm83vincent

good
i would copy it to my blog
the REAL picture is to be disclosed anytime, i guess…..and najib is shaking now…
on 06 Jul 2007 at 1:49 pm84ham

Any monkey with half a brain will tell you this photo is 100% doctored!
on 06 Jul 2007 at 2:10 pm85The Malaysian Blogosphere » Blog Archive » malaysianbillboard: Altantuya Murder Trial - So who did it?

[...] also carried a report on Tian Chua’s blog where he posted a picture entitled French Dinner for 3. I found it amusing, read Tian Chua’s blog and I believe you will [...]
on 06 Jul 2007 at 2:37 pm86HandsomeGuy

Hey Chua, who is that sexy girl sitting beside the fat guy? looks cute…nice dress too..
on 06 Jul 2007 at 3:14 pm87PhotoshopUser

Chua, this is a cheap way to promote your blog…if i have some C4 i will do the same thing to you too..(for abusing photoshop)
on 06 Jul 2007 at 4:01 pm88fulat

Now i know, najib is jesus and the women beside her should be his…
on 06 Jul 2007 at 11:30 pm89Kelvin Ng

TC,

I was dissapointed with you for posting the doctored picture. But now I am utterly disgusted with you for your stand not to apologise. Btw, doctoring images cannot be considered as an art!

Please do consider that you have doctored the image without qualifying that it was an “artist’s” impression or that it is doctored! You only clarified it a day after. Seems to me you posted it and when most ppl were upset you came up with a flimsy excuse why the posting was done.

No matter what is the reasons or excuse, it ain’t justifiable to doctor the image of a deceased and implying that it is not doctored!

Why do I contend that you did imply that it is not doctored? Well, below the images. you wrote there “Najib doesnâ€™t want to be reminded with THIS romantic event” (EMPHASIS MINE)

With the use of “THIS”, you come across as suggesting that this dinner as seen in the images actually took place!

I am calling on you in the name of integrity, decency and honour to tender your apology to all in particular to the deceased and the family!

Please don’t let pride prevent you from doing what which is honorable! I believe upon your apology, we will still be proud of your struggles but now it seems your struggles are tainted with the very fibre you preach against! You are indeed a politician!
on 07 Jul 2007 at 12:03 am90MOHD FAZLI BIN WAN CHIK

bagus tian saya menyokong anda memasuk kan gambar najib dengan attantuya
on 07 Jul 2007 at 12:04 am91MOHD FAZLI BIN WAN CHIK

kalau ada gambar lagi masukkan lagi
on 07 Jul 2007 at 1:46 am92KEadilan

Saudara Tian Chua!
Saya betul2 terkilan dengan penyiaran gambar super impose ini, ini akan digunakan oleh mereka untuk menidakkan kebenaran. dan jika adapun ia akan dikatakan super impose walaupun ianya asli. jadi fikir2 kan la. ini ibarat meludah kelangit, akhirnya kena sendiri, jadi walaupun saudara telah banyak kali masuk lokap/ISA, dengar penyiaran gambar ini, saya dah rasa hilang kepercayaan pada saudara, jadi lain kali fikirkan menggunakan otak bukan dengan kepala lutut.
Harap saudara Komen!!!
on 07 Jul 2007 at 1:47 am93Adil

Harap saudara buangkan gambar ini segera, jangan kerana ini nama KEADILAN akan bertambah dicemuh oleh masyarakat
on 07 Jul 2007 at 1:48 am94Aiman

Berpolitik biar betul, anta tu Ketua Penerangan jaga imej sikit,
tengok sekali pun tahu , itu gambar palsu,â€¦.
jangan taruh ..
jatuh saham Keadilan jeâ€¦
byeâ€¦bye

saya sokong dengan pendapat ini>..
on 07 Jul 2007 at 1:51 am95Bodo

Tian Chua!!!
Anda adalah ketua Penerangan KEadilan!! Jadi kalau anda menyiarkan benda2 palsu, jadi secara tak lansung semua perkara yang anda terangkan akan dipersialkan oleh masyarakat!!!! USE YOUR BRAIN!!!!
on 07 Jul 2007 at 6:22 am96keadilan

hi,asian cup is starting soon..
lets give malaysian full support.wish malaysian football team will play their best and give all out.i hope this asian cup matches will be played fairly with integrity and with high class attitude without violent.most importantly players from every country must show a good example at the pitch to educate the younger generation of footballer and the one who watches their matches by playing fair without violent.
once again i want to wish malaysian football team good luck and all the best!thank you.
take care..

writen by,
KEADILAN
on 07 Jul 2007 at 9:07 am97phiz

kalau sebeginilah cara awak, ermm…. mmg patutlah ramai yg lari dari parti KEADILAN. Ramai kaki putar belit.

chua, awak pikir dengan gambar super-impose ini dapt menghasut rakyat warganegara MALAYSIA yg berakal terperangkap dengan perjuangan dusta awak itu ? mimpilah. pergi berambus singaporelah !!!

patutlah ramai yg angkat kaki dari duduk semeja dengan awak.
on 07 Jul 2007 at 9:26 am98Aljandakaya

Pemuda Umno kutuk tindakan Tian Chua

KUALA LUMPUR: Pergerakan Pemuda Umno mengutuk sekeras-kerasnya perbuatan biadap dan tidak bertanggungjawab Ketua Penerangan Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR), Tian Chua yang menyiarkan gambar palsu mengaitkan Timbalan Perdana Menteri, Datuk Seri Najib Razak dengan wanita Mongolia, Altantuya Shaaribu di blog webnya.

Ketua Pemuda Umno, Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein, dalam kenyataan yang dikeluarkan di sini, semalam, berkata perbuatan Tian Chua yang berunsur fitnah dan hasutan itu dengan jelas mencerminkan sikap pemimpin PKR lain yang turut bersekongkol dan sanggup melakukan apa saja, termasuk membelakangkan kebenaran dan keadilan demi kepentingan politik sempit mereka.

â€œTian Chua yang sering menggunakan NGO (pertubuhan bukan kerajaan) asing dan tempatan untuk menghentam pemimpin kita serta memburuk-burukkan negara, kali ini sudah keterlaluan dan kurang ajar apabila membuat pengakuan dengan angkuh (yang beliau menyiarkan gambar palsu itu) tetapi enggan untuk memohon maaf,â€ kata Hishammuddin dalam kenyataan yang dikeluarkan di sini, semalam.
on 07 Jul 2007 at 9:52 am99samdar

Salam Perpaduan…
Sekali imbas, nampak seperti gambar palsu je… Jadi harap tuan dapat pastikan ketulenan gambar ini sebelum disiarkan. Ini akan memberikan imej yang negatif kepada pembangkang jua terutamanya kepada PKR dan PAS.
on 07 Jul 2007 at 10:49 am100Torpedoflash

Dari sini boleh kita lihat mentaliti orang yg mentelaah ruangan ini. Semua org tahu gambar itu superimpose….Budak-budak sekolah rendah pun tahu!!! Yang penting dan perlu diteliti ialah cara dan mesej apa yg hendak disampaikan. Kita boleh lihat didalam akhbar-akhbar harian, betapa melompatnya sesetengah pihak dengan penyebaran superimpose ini…adakah ini tidak melambangkan mentaliti murahan dan ceteknya fikiran mereka yg terlalu cepat membuat telahan. Syabas…kalau itu niat dan objektif yg hendak dicapai…saudara TC serba sedikit telah mendekati objektif!
on 07 Jul 2007 at 10:59 am101Torpedoflash

…dan seperkara lagi…setahu saya, saudara TC tidak ada membuat kenyataan bahawa gambar itu ialah gambar yg menyabitkan mereka bertiga dari segi kontek ceritanya…sekadar gimmick sahaja! Mengapa terlalu cepat melompat? Apa bezanya gambar itu dgn kartun politik?! Jangan sampai kita meng”kartun”kan pemikiran kita dgn meniliti gambar itu. cuba tuan2 dan puan2 duduk diam…rileks dan fikir…errrr…apalah agak2 nya mesej yang hendak disampaikan…hmmmm…
on 07 Jul 2007 at 2:22 pm102PAK TUAN

YOU’RE STUPID POLITICIAN!!!!
Once upon a time, you were somebody in this country and I had respect you for a while, but its suprising me you suddenly change your carracter as a stupid guy!!!
Please, just continue your life as a normal person and quit from political stages. Dirty tricky like this show us the real who you are. What ashamed PKR’s members like you???
on 07 Jul 2007 at 5:03 pm103sam

waa..so many comments…i think the main thing is not the picture..but the story behind…fikirkanlah…politic is clean..but..orang yang berpolitik itu yang ????????
on 07 Jul 2007 at 5:53 pm104Ramani

reading all the previous posts, i can only come to a conclusion that most of you that have commented definitely have 3rd world mentality. have any of you come across pictures of george bush being edited and dressed up to look like a clown, a tiger, in a bikini suit and stuffs? this isn’t even to that extent. why make a big fuss even when george bush himself isn’t bothered? this is the typical malaysian mentality. we could be advanced in many thing, yet we still act like uneducated brats. i read through the whole post and i do not even see a single line commenting about the picture. and there is no need for him to do any explanation whatsoever regarding the picture as it has nothing to do with the post. illustrations are needed at times and i don’t see anything so wrong with the picture.
on 07 Jul 2007 at 9:02 pm105next

what next…
ramai dah ahli pkr keluar pati…
adakah ini alasan TC untuk keluar dari PKR?
penyokong2 ‘gila’ TC biar hati2. sila lihat sejarah lalu.
ramai penyokong2 bermati-matian tiba2 ketuanya… ??
apa agenda TC sebenarnya?
tq
on 07 Jul 2007 at 11:49 pm106Obi

Great work Mr.Chua….I rushed to ur blog after I finished with Berita Harian’s bull shit….I know its bull shit, I just went there to know wat type of goverment backing granpa story they will include.
Mr.Chua, U’re brave man, and Malaysia really need you, I’m not there…I think this is fortunate time for me not to be in Malaysia, I learn we have most corrupted goverment in the world…and yet they kept on singing song ‘Alhamdulilah Shukur Nikmat Malaysia Maju Rakyat Selamat’….but actualy that not true at all.
Backinglah BN dan kerajaan barulah boleh selamat…I’m from ‘Kampung’, never hate Malays but I really hate UMNO youth ….they should wipe my ass as return for me to teach them to be Good, tolerate, sensitive, caring leaders.
Their ‘keris’ issue never ever off from my mind, I wish Samy can show Kalaripayat and MIC guys can show some Kungfu.
UMNO and BN no need to proof anything, my friend told me he received RM 250 to cross BN at IJOK….hahha…..Berita Harian papers should read in toilet only and don’t bring it out from there.
Please don’t remove above picture, at least it give sense and allow others to imagine such incident took place. I know it fake, but that picture give more information to people. This will be distributed and people can consider who is doing what. This picture will reach village folks who didn’t have money for even a dial up connection.
I heard tht Malaysian goverment build mosque in Bosnia….quit expensive, Mr.Chua….I want to warn them, that is my father’s money who paid tax till he died……’haram tau, guna duit orang’

Continue your great work Mr.Chua, I will support you, believe me you have allot of silent supporters, who don’t show up as UMNO supporters do.

Obie
on 07 Jul 2007 at 11:54 pm107tieh siaw siong

a below the belt attack. seriously cheap.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 12:17 am108Mason From Kuching

Only fools ( those who never seen Altantuya’s pictures/photo’s) would belieive such anomaly. And of course, this is an old story by especially the ruling BN Junta.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 12:23 am109Stupidity is worse than crime? | Malaysia Buzz with YeinJee

[...] are condemning Parti Keadilan Rakyat’s (PKR) information chief Tian Chua for his “French dinner for 3” doctored pic that poked fun at Najib Razak. Whatever reason or whatever humour he was trying [...]
on 08 Jul 2007 at 12:52 am110WilliamT

Hi,
To everyone… no matter you are from which corner of malaysia. Please lar, if got evidence, please directly post to news. Dun making rumors here.
To politician, please do not bull shit outside. No matter from which party you are. If you really working and thinking of public, work truly. Dun only mouth’s working but hand didnt work. Be smart, dun make those ppl who support you feel that u are stupid..!!!
on 08 Jul 2007 at 1:03 am111bennyloh

I never have been acquainted..
http://malaysiancartoons.blogspot.com/2007/07/i-never-met.html
on 08 Jul 2007 at 6:57 am112IMMalaysian

TC -
Probably you shall change it to the comic version…. then all ppl will shut up… i can suggest you to put the following conversation:

Najis: “I dont know why i’m in the photo. I’m Swear I never met her b4, until she been blasted”

“ParkingDa”: “My Family proud of me for murders someone….wow”
Athantuya “Ghost Mode”: ” Jerks, comes accompany me…..”

Malaysian - Two of them is 8N -UUMMNNO0 Leader wow…. do you feel proud ah?
You guys shall question to government… Why they dont’ want to published the photo…. we have the rights to know this…. It’s regardless who inside that photo…. Stupiakk…
TC, I support you… but just the way you did it is a bit too stupid….. change it to comics…..mah… everyday draw one… draw until they vomit blood…
on 08 Jul 2007 at 7:47 am113Kong Lok Soy

I guess Najib is sitting on the floor…. am I right?… hahahaha
on 08 Jul 2007 at 8:36 am114long

super-imposed? SUPER?? stupid imposed bole la.. aloo kawan, u tara baca punya org ka? please dont maku us dsappoint wit keadilan laa
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:03 am115Gorro

Jangan terus kutuk gambar ini. Walaupun ia terang2 nampak superimpose, mungking ia ada maksud tersirat, macam sajak la jugak. Cuba fikir kenapa gambar ini dibuat, mungkin ader sebabnya.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:10 am116swinger69ers

Hmm…super-imposed definitely. Next time u wanna do sum realistic super-impose, pass it on 2 me..hehehe…i can do better ones..
But then again, it cud b a political stunt… who knows maybe Tian Chua is WORKING wif Najib in d background…He posted a super=imposed pics (purposely) so it will look like d foundation of althantuya relationship wif Najib is actually a fake one, and Najib can use this pic as a public denial wif d saying of “The pic is super-imposed..it is not real, i am innocent!! and d people must know and support me out frm this outrageous slander”. Then his political stand will b stronger, even KJ cannot do anything abt it..hehehe… later, upon sum humiliation view frm d public to Tian Chua, he’ll b ousted as a ‘desperado’ in d political community.. but who knows, Najib & d gang already prepared sum amount to his offshore acct for helping him to prove d illicit innocence of the case…Ended up, both person in a win win situation…
Not neccessarily whut i post here is true…but imagine d possibilities.. because politics can b juz as fake as d picture..
Juz my 69 cents….
Cheers
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:14 am117eranona

Pada pandangan saya gambar palsu ini dipaparkan oleh blog ini sebagai ‘test market’ je… Takkan TC begitu b-d-h nak siar gambar ni tanpa sebab. Dan saya yakin gambar tu masih ada dan saya nanti kemunculannya. Ke TC nak tengok DPM cakap apa-apa dulu baru nak keluar gambar tu….hehehehehe Kuat gurau juga TC ni….
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:24 am118Pist Off With The Case

With regards to today’s The Star, “Apologise or face action, BN leaders tell Tian Chua”, ignore them Tian Chua. First, ask them, “what is there to apologise over?” Secondly, ask them, “is that woman Altantuya?”. Third, ask them, “why are you so sensitive if that is not Altantuya? Remember in Malaysia there is a phrase siapa makan cili dialah yang terasa pedasnya. Why on earth are you guys so sensitive?”. Fourthly, ask them, “did I in anyway put a caption in the photo that says this is THE PHOTO that Burmaa Oyunchimeg was mentioning about?”. Fifthly, ask the BN, “hey guys, do you guys follow the Altantuya trial or not?. If not just shut up. Read the caption and interpret the photo properly. You cannot just interpret the photo and read the caption seperately. Assumptions make an S out of a person.”

Well done Tian Chua. Many of the BN people are shouting shouting and shouting asking you to apologise. At the end of the news report, it was stated that Umno Youth is studying the law closely before lodging a police report. You see Tian Chua, those who shouted and shouted, asking you to apologise, DID NOT even know if you should apologise or not.!!!!! If they were DEAD SURE that you were wrong, then they would have straight away made a police report!!! Why on earth do they need to study the law?

Aiseyman. Kemayan ATC has a good law degree program LOL
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:53 am119kenapa?

apa beza antara n***b dengan an**r i*rahim?

org yg tidak bersalah mungkin dituduh, tetapi ada yg mungkin bersalah terlepas begitu sahaja.
many conspiracy we do not know…
on 08 Jul 2007 at 9:56 am120You Know Who

TC,

That was a good ‘linkage’ to the court case. Hope that justice will prevail in the nation of 20 million which has been treated ‘differently” by racial background.
Picture can relate to a world of ’story’!!!!
on 08 Jul 2007 at 10:33 am121anwar

nampak macam tak betul je,tak tahulah kalau betul,kalau betul memalukan negara.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 1:16 pm122BN Scumbags

for the first time ur blog is so heated! congrats!

i only see scumbags received orders from their superior to attack ur blog. but anyway, i smell fear in scumbags and their superior.

hey BN Scumbags! Lets turn this into some war, since i notice scumbags like using rude words. BN scumbags are uncivilized anyway. Yet they think they are more high class than us ordinary rakyat. Take out ur fucking keris and show the whole world scumbags, i dare u not. And scumbags are easily provoked.

in the next election please vote any opposition party, be it PAS, PKR or DAP, as long as not fucking BN that ruin our live. AT LEAST there will be still hope to save malaysia.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 2:17 pm123Apadia

ni gambar apa dia.. adik aku pun boleh buat
on 08 Jul 2007 at 4:08 pm124r-u-talkin-2-me?

gambar tipu tu……….!!!!
on 08 Jul 2007 at 5:13 pm125BN sucks

What do we get by voting from BN? Price increase for almost everything and it never stops. For all of you that still want to continue voting for BN, don’t complain for high petrol or toll prices.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 5:19 pm126STewart Low KS

Just a Image for FUN!!!

Ask the Malaysian Government, Release the Real Photo.

Dr Chua(Dr in politic,respect u!)

Go for It! and Good Job for Malaysian!!
on 08 Jul 2007 at 5:23 pm127najib

lawak !!! you should create some more creative pictures!!
on 08 Jul 2007 at 5:24 pm128najib

najib=baginda=parti keadilan=killer
on 08 Jul 2007 at 6:04 pm129reformist501

Tian Chua,

Anda telah memberi BN satu point kuat untuk defend Najib Razak.
Aiyoh. Plan your strategy la.. or AT LEAST put photo caption there **this pic were an imagination of the blog author**.

Resign la Tian Chua, kasi saja your position to those yang lebih bijak dalam strategy a.k.a Public Relation

Sincerely (I mean it)
on 08 Jul 2007 at 6:12 pm130reformist501

see what Najib Razak commented about this, today (8 July)?

“Mereka (PKR) mengada-adakan cerita & bukti”

You brought shame and bad name to PKR. Please resign!
If you dont, you’re just the same as those you ‘lawan’.

‘Lawan’ tetap lawan.
on 08 Jul 2007 at 6:53 pm131Mazidul Boroi

Aku tak amik dadah,aku tak salah, hahahahah
on 08 Jul 2007 at 8:40 pm132Wind of change

TC,
Sindiran tajam!!!! We know that PKR has got the original photo, Just wait!! Bravo!! TC
on 08 Jul 2007 at 10:03 pm133Pist Off With The Case

Tian Chua, be happy to note that you have another supporter ! he or she has another photo which is modified from yours http://politics101malaysia.blogsome.com/2007/07/03/the-mystery-altantuya-najib-abdul-razak-photo/
on 08 Jul 2007 at 10:08 pm134Kit Sun

Hi Tian Chua

Kit here. Still at it since university times? Good photoshop work but its on a slippery legal slope my man.

email me.

kit
on 08 Jul 2007 at 11:46 pm135wan

Hi,
Sekali tengok macam btul, berkali2 tengok betul2 memang tak betul.
Dinner table tu hanya untuk couple saja…..perhati table sebelah too close ………..
on 09 Jul 2007 at 12:08 am136tengok t v

wahyo ! The strong arms of UMNO is after you, my man. Take cover !
on 09 Jul 2007 at 2:58 am137The Perfect Crime (2) « elizabeth wong

[...] “Dinner for 3″ even snagged the prized Sunday Star editorial and a rather disturbing frontpage headline story in Nanyang’s Sunday evening edition (see below). [...]
on 09 Jul 2007 at 8:13 am138SAMUEL

hello…. i am eager to see the real photo of atlantuya and najib …
any info please repy to this message.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 8:16 am139SAMUEL

if najib is responsible… i hope pak lah will not hide the truth..
malaysia is getting popular now….for it’s corrupted goverment agencies.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 9:51 am140Yahead

How damp stupid …..Tian Chua..use this fake photo…are you planning to leave PKR to follow Izam, but before that you make funny thing..?
on 09 Jul 2007 at 9:57 am141Evil Man

This is just an internet joke, just like many many others… what’s the big fuss over it?! TC is right about it, if u r not a thief, then why r u afraid of the policeman?
on 09 Jul 2007 at 10:36 am142zidane

mcm budak2…….elok letak gambo bugs bunny lagi comel
on 09 Jul 2007 at 12:28 pm143Pist Off With The Case

Hello Tian Chua. It’s me again. From what I see, I see the true colors of our Local Press and that of the BN as well. I see that they only tell me part of the story. I see that they only tell me things that make BN look good and not the other way round. It’s a one-way situation in BN as I always see it and that’s why I would never join BN.

A very good example is shown in today’s (9 July 2007) New Straits Times. “Chua: It’s Not An Issue”. In this article, it was mentioned that “However, a visit to Tian Chuaâ€™s website revealed that even his blog readers criticised the posting of the obviously superimposed picture of Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak with Abdul Razak Baginda and a woman.”

Just because some people critisised, it doesn’t necessary mean the whole of Malaysians critise your fantasy art work! However, NO! I was reported that your readers critise your art work. Actually, there are also those who gave you the thumbs up since the second day of the day the first comment started and I am one of them.

And in today’s NST also, Najib says that PKR lacks morals and principles. Again, I see that “they” print things that glorify them. This is what Najib said,

“Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Razak, opening the Batu Kawan Umno delegates conference in Penang, said the baseless accusations levelled at him, Prime Minister Datuk Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi and other leaders clearly indicated that PKR was unethical.”

Firstly, I think the word unethical should be used correctly. Secondly, I think the word “accusation” should be used where appropriate. You see, where in your blog did you accuse them ? Where Where Oh Where did you ACCUSE Najib ?

Tian Chua boleh. Let Tian Chua be the next PM
on 09 Jul 2007 at 12:33 pm144Bravo

Dear Brother Tian Chua,

after reading the press, I googled for your webpage. You have done no wrong and you need not worry. I am a lawyer by profession and I know the law. Bravo bro.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 12:50 pm145kuakkuakkuak

whatlah u all ! ever heard of political cartoons ?? dis one also one to go jail when kene hidung sendiri. if he do, ok nevermine when peolple do waaa like sheeet only. where got murder in malaysia ? she never get into malaysia one ask the immigration she not here how to murder here. where got case right?
on 09 Jul 2007 at 1:44 pm146street_fighter_606

Mr TC,

1. You might have the real picture but you posted the backup picture just to enjoy the game. If there is no real picture, i might think you have comitted seriuos and greatest stupid action in your life, the party and the people who seeking justice for Altantuya’s case..
2. If you have comitted this stupid action, please resign from the party or do something to pull back your pants to its original positions.
3. Everybody knows the truth, DO NOT confuse their mindset on the truth !
SF606
on 09 Jul 2007 at 2:25 pm147John

I agree with some commentors, you should label the picture as a superimposed picture, or make it more obvious that it is fabricated. Otherwise what is your arguement? …that some people are NOT honest? Hello!

I believe in freedom of speech but you also have to be open and honest as to the speech you use.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 3:33 pm148Suhaib

Far from putting a disclaimer to declare the photo as fake the title to the picture above ‘Najib doesnâ€™t want to be reminded with this romantic event’ clearly claims that the event (and therefore the picture) is real. This label is a clear ground for Najib to initiate a defamation suit against Tian Chua.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 3:35 pm149hero

Hi, geng…don’t play-play…k! the truth is out there…..
on 09 Jul 2007 at 3:51 pm150Sunday Princess

I think your pic was very funny in a Monthy Pyton way, but when I sit down and watch Life of Brian I am aware that I’m watching a comedy. I not labeled as “forgerie” people might actually think that this picture is true, and we don’t want to confuse the people, right? John is right, the freedom of speech does not give anyone the right to mislead people’s opinion and it MUST be used wisely.

You have a great country, you should be proud of being part of the people that keeps it moving. Keep up with the good work!
on 09 Jul 2007 at 4:30 pm151theresa

this is a fake the table is set for 2 and the girl is not attantuya grow up
on 09 Jul 2007 at 5:38 pm152Pist Off With The Case

Dear Tian Chua,

Just to cheer u up, please watch this video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sExy0RhEbsc

You will laugh your heads off. Listen to the song “Who Let The Dogs Out…. Woof Woof Woof “….

Not my creation though
on 09 Jul 2007 at 5:49 pm153Rational thinking

actually this is only to show what will that be in the real photo (somebody hide it and please show the real pic so people will not doubt about whether what is true and wrong)and this is definitely not the real one..tian chua intension is just try to show you guys what it will be if the real photo out..he did’nt say that its the real pic…even a small 3 yrs old kid will know this is a fake pic so please don’t be too overeact with this and whats funny is that they trying to make this ridicilous photo so huge as its nothing to be surprised of. to break this off..somebody please show the real photo
on 09 Jul 2007 at 6:20 pm154Insider

As long as the PM has issues with the DPM, your website shall remain accessible to all Malaysians.
on 09 Jul 2007 at 6:35 pm155Objective

Some sharp-minded readers have understood the objective of the pic, the wise and brave person(s) has contributed without considering much about his personal well-being, the truth prevails!
on 09 Jul 2007 at 6:50 pm156Anonymous

This pic looks real enough to me. Najib is just slumped a bit in his chair, probably from eating a big dinner and drinking too much. What else do you expect from BN politicians?
on 09 Jul 2007 at 7:08 pm157Matt

THAT PHOTOGRAPH IS PHOTOSHOPPED, EDITED OR MANIPULATED!
Why? Read Below:

1.) Firstly, check out the resolution of the female’s face to the rest of the photograph.

2.) Check out the very faint white glow around the head of the female, this is caused when the image is feathered so that the edge pixels blend.

3.) The lighting is evidently from a different ’source’.

4.) The image does appear to be pasted onto the females body, as can be seen by the different skin tones and composition.

Heared about this through the BBC news website, but just wanted to set the record straight. I don’t know anything about or anybody associated with this ’scam’, but i just wanted to point out that this cannot be the subject of international news as the image is fake!!!
on 09 Jul 2007 at 8:00 pm158HHHFSF

EXCELLENT JOB …..FRIEND…..MALAYSIAN APPRECIATE OF IT!!!
DO MORE!!!!
on 09 Jul 2007 at 8:44 pm159WilliamT

Dear Tian Chua,

Why you not put the title as “Last Dinner”???? Adui.. you really memalukan your own party, the leader of the party, the consultant of the party… also make a shame to our country ex-DPM…. He already shame, you make him more shame… haizzzzz….
on 09 Jul 2007 at 11:39 pm160bennyloh

Comedy,
http://malaysiancartoons.blogspot.com/2007/07/comical-pudding.html
on 10 Jul 2007 at 2:04 am161next

TC,
Berapa ramaikah pengundi2 di malaysia yang faham dengan nilai2 seni yang cuba digambarkan oleh TC.
Cuba buat kira2 mudah;
Kalau 30% saja yg faham dgn nilai2 seni tu, maknanya ada lagi 70% yang tak faham (bukan ramai org boleh faham dgn nilai2 seni). Apa yg 70% ni faham ialah, ianya gambar itu palsu spt yg telah diakui oleh TC sendiri. 70% ini yg akan memberi kesan negetif pada PKR. Jadi saya tak nampak feadahnya gambar tersebut dibuat untuk menarik pengundi menyokong PKR.
Tolong beri tahu saya bagaimana gambar palsu @ bernilai seni tinggi ini boleh membantu PKR dalam pilihan raya akan datang.
Begitu juga dgn penyokong2 setia TC, sila berikan pandangan anda bagaimana gambar ini boleh memberikan kelebihan pd PKR dalam menghadapi pilihraya akan datang?
Kebenaran hendaklah ditegakan….
TK
on 10 Jul 2007 at 2:17 am162monsterfacial

Just my 2 sen…….. the picture is as fake as my own works of amy yip…..putting that aside. What about the question that Karpal has repeatedly asked………What about the immigration records……Who is the ONE that instructed for the deletion of Altantuya’s records to cover up her entry into Malaysia………Once you find the ONE person …then and only then can the culprit be instigated……forget rumours and what have you……we poor innocent tax payers just want to know who was the ONE to wholly profit from the sale of the Submarine from the Russians to the Malaysians. Is poor Baginda is being a scapgoat for someone else? Can he get military grade explosives in a nights notice? Was Altantuya’s body blown in a jungle setting or in the sea……. I for one would have blown her body in the sea to hide the fact…because I am a lot more smarter…….. With sooo many rumours around. who is to protect our integrity as malaysians…..I for one just came back from overseas and was horrified with the headlines overseas about the case………Brothers…this is no Canny Ong case……it does not involve a high ranking person in politics…..Can we proudly say that the mongolian girl was at fault here for being murdered in our country…….We can only say one thing …..is was indeed a malaysian that murdered the poor mongolian girl….Who we do not know…..?????? For now…..someone must own up or risk more international media attention….Again just my humble 2 sens worth
on 10 Jul 2007 at 2:41 am163alkepong

Penipuan yang menarik..
tapi perlu touch up yang lebih..
tahniah TC kerana berjaya menghangatkan suasana pembicaraan kes altantuya..

LAWAN TETAP LAWAN
JOGET SAMPAI PENGSAN
on 10 Jul 2007 at 8:59 am164malas nak layan

gambar super impose tak sama nilainya dengan kartun politik. jangan sesekali bermain api. kita negara pertama yang ada akta komunikasi dan multimedia. nasihat saya; kalau nak cuba, teruskanlah siarkan gambar tersebut di internet.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:01 am165abbie

Dear TC,
you’ve done a great job!!
to be frankly, i m pretty sad to look at those comments that just talking about the “fake” picture, do they noted ur message?…..
that’s really “black” behind the politic, and everyone know that!!

i’m quite agreed with Obie’s opinion, as a Malaysia citizen, i m really disppointted with our government’s behaviors. “Dare to do but not dare to admit”. What kind of democratic country we have? how many of us know our right as a citizen? what kind of education system we have in our country? how the govt spend our tax money? is everyone of us treated equally under the govt’s policy? do the govt really concern the citizen? or they just concern about their own benefits?………….
just think !
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:16 am166unRational Thinking

Mr. Rational Thinking,

As u mentioned before, “even a small 3 yrs old kid will know this is a fake pic so please donâ€™t be too overeact with this”.

i agree with u and.. we also don’t mind if the pic was sent by a 3 years old kid. but, u tell me who stick it up on the WORLD WIDE WEB? a 3 years old kid aa??

it not supposed to come out from a matured political leader like TC was. he seems shouting all over the world to gain cheap publicity (or showing off his stupidity). and even a few of people with rational thinking like u want to join him (???).

please go ahead and make my day.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:18 am167Advocate

I think the doctored image is an excellent expression of imagination and creativity. It is also promotes the freedom of expression and speech. IT is obviously a fake picture that is intended for pun rather than harm. ANy reasonably, intilligent person with some cow sense, reading this blog can see that. IF they cant see the humour in this, nor can they be intelligent enough to read between the lines, perhaps they deserve to be ruled by a regime that has masked information from the public thus far…………..Good work to the author…………..
on 10 Jul 2007 at 11:23 am168Pist Off With The Case

Tian Chua, now BN is getting really desperate. Look at the news in The Star http://www.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2007/7/10/nation/18259162&sec=nation - 12 quit PKR in Terengganu. People who quit BN, they don’t mention. I tell you what lah Tian Chua. You get 13 people from PKR, ask them to resign from PKR. Then ask them to join BN. Then ask them to resign from BN. Then, with their letters, publish in your website, “13 people left BN because they have no confidence in BN’s leadership”.

What’s the big deal lah BN. ?
on 10 Jul 2007 at 11:46 am169iphonebeep

have you read the utusan?? are you going to get sued??

http://utusan.com.my/utusan/content.asp?y=2007&dt=0710&pub=Utusan_Malaysia&sec=Muka_Hadapan&pg=mh_07.htm
on 10 Jul 2007 at 11:57 am170XXX

MR chua..this will make u a big trouble.please remove the “photo” from web..and the picture was not a real source.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 12:39 pm171uutjutjut

TIAN CHUA!!! THE END JUSTIFIED THE MEAN!!! YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN…YOU CERTAINLY KNOW WHAT I MEAN…
on 10 Jul 2007 at 12:44 pm172uutjutjut

YOU WANT TO MAKE THE MONKEY JUMP NERVOUSLY…DONT SAW OFF THE TREE…JUST LIT A SMALL BONFIRE AT THE TREE BASE…JUST AS WHAT YOU DONE WITH THE ‘FRENCH DINNER’…THEY ARE VERY NERVOUS NOW…
on 10 Jul 2007 at 1:00 pm173å¤©ä¸Šäººé—´ Down To Earth » Blog Archive » æ·»å¼ºçš„â€œ3äººæ³•å›½é¤â€åˆæˆç…§

[...] è¿™å°±æ˜¯åˆŠç™»åœ¨æ·»å¼ºçš„éƒ¨è½æ ¼è€Œå¼•èµ·è½©ç„¶å¤§æ³¢çš„â€œ3äººæ³•å›½é¤â€åˆæˆç…§ã€‚ [...]
on 10 Jul 2007 at 1:16 pm174ererer

hahahaha
After reading all the comments, I concluded most of you are morons. Of course it’s a fake photo. TC didn’t ask you to judge it, he merely tickle your brain to to think on the real issue.

If his intention was to defame anyone, I think he would be clever enough to make or hire somebody to make a flawless one.

Use your eyes to see but most importantly, use your brain too to comprehend the issues at hand.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 3:10 pm175Justice

It takes lotsa courage for the Opposition party to challenge the Government each time. No doubt this is a fake pic, but salutation shd be given to Tian Chua for demanding fair hearing behind this Murder case. How many of us here actually dare to speak up knowing we will “offends” the authorities?

Moving on to 50 yrs of independancy, Malaysia should improve to be a prosperous and democratic country BUT NOT being monopolised and jeorpadised further. We are Rakyat Malaysia and we love to be a Malaysian, so dont abuse it
on 10 Jul 2007 at 3:27 pm176Justice

Btw, it seems like many here actually question Tian Chua’s integrity of posing this pic up.. But how come no one actually Question the integrity of our Immigration dept, Why the records of Altantuya and her frens can be deleted that off easily..?? Who can actually have the power to control our govt officer to make the changes??? Even the 2 police officer abetted in this case, Who is the one who gave them the order??? Remember, they are from UTK, their job is to protect our leaders in M’sia. So many Question marks but no one even seems to bother.

This pic is no big deal. If I understand Tian Chua correctly, He is just reminding and wanted the explanation for all the allegations make against our DPM. Why everyone responded so negatively?! We shd be more concern to our legal side, for them to be impartial and transparents towards this case.

Justice seeker.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 3:59 pm177KKTan

Althought I really do not like the curent rulling parties BN. It seems unethical that TC using this cheapskape method to politicize this issue.
It’s too early and unfair to debate on this issue yet as none of us have really seen the real picture. There is no need of pressuring the DPM to explain anything yet till the real picture surfaced and exposed to the public.
By then, there will be no hiding anymore for the DPM. I think TC and many of us will feel more ‘pleasurable’ when the real picture is exposed rather than creating all the publicity with a picture like this one…
on 10 Jul 2007 at 6:14 pm178Evolve

Your prank fell flat, dude. I wish you had immediately either taken it down, or inserted something to say that it was doctored … especially when misinterpretations arose. People, whether willingly or not, could confuse, no? — Particularly the not- so-bright-UMNO types.

So long, kawan…
on 10 Jul 2007 at 6:16 pm179Concerned Malaysian

Nice… now you got yourself a lawsuit. Please resign
on 10 Jul 2007 at 8:38 pm180kitty kat

Hi Mr. Chua

I love your photo. is there anything more saucy like najib and his missile? the tiny ones which fit inside a leaky submarine.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:14 pm181Mackie

how on earth you cannot differentiate a photo that being superimposed with original? yet you fight like it’s true, how on earth could i believe you ever after this? i don’t believe you, you’re too obssessive and greedy to be a politician. go back home learn how to be politician, not a cheap politician like you’re right now!
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:17 pm182BN Scumbags

BN scumbags don’t switch attention.

Bring the criminals to justice!!

AND WOW SO MANY VOICES OUT OF A SUDDEN HOW MUCH BN PAY YOU TO WRITE????

HAVE SOME SANITY IN YOURSELF PLEASE, GO WRITE SOMETHING MORE USEFUL FOR THE RAKYAT. GO SPAM SAMMY VELLU’S BLOG GO!
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:20 pm183BN Scumbags

NO SERIOUSLY HOW MUCH?? HOW MUCH NAJIB OR ABDULLAH PAY YOU TO WRITE THIS?? RM200???

WOW SO CHEAPSKATE YA???
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:23 pm184BN Scumbags

I KNOW YOU WONT ANSWER MY QUESTION BECAUSE ITS NOT IN YOUR CONTRACT (writing contract) TO DO SO, REASON IM USING CAPS TO GET UR ATTENTION YOU BN SCUMBAGS.

RM200 PLUS A PROMOTE???

OR WHAT???

C’MON MAN IM MORE INTERESTED IN YOUR WRITING CONTRACT!!
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:24 pm185NAJIB

SEE I CAN CHANGE MY NICK!! OH WOW!! SO MANY PEOPLE RESPONDING WOW WOW!!
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:27 pm186BN Scumbags

SINCE YOU CAN SELL YOUR DIGNITY, PM ME IN SECRET I WOULD LIKE TO BUY YOUR DIGNITY WITH A HIGHER PRICE!!!

YOU DONT NEED TO WRITE FOR ME, JUST QUIT LIFE.
on 10 Jul 2007 at 9:35 pm187adam dEaLova

serioushitly superimposed snap. U better brain a better idea man. Better hit the facts of the case instead.

Nice try anyway, TC. Shame on you..
on 10 Jul 2007 at 11:05 pm188Go Najib, Sue Tian Chua! « Bloginie

[...] Jul 10th, 2007 by ginielim Since Najib claimed that he does not know Altantuya during Ijok by election in April, thus he has no reason to feel threatened by Tian Chua with his “French Dinner for 3″. [...]
on 11 Jul 2007 at 6:05 am189E Contrario » Blog Archive » This is not…

[...] me invite you to look at the picture in my post “French dinner for 3″ once again. Please look within the frame. Who are the people in the [...]
on 11 Jul 2007 at 10:46 am190baginda

Najib tak penting dalam ganbar ini, yang penting aku baginda dan kekasih ku….kami bersama
on 11 Jul 2007 at 11:21 am191NO BIG DEAL

What’s the big fuss… any fool can tell its a fake pic. Besides, thats not Altantuya. Anyway, couldn’t give a rats ass bout that greedy mongolian. Bet her whole family is into it too…

RAZAK BAGINDA… you hv my support!!
on 11 Jul 2007 at 12:19 pm192buenos

Of all these comments. It just shows that we the Malaysian are so dump. Chua knows it is a fake foto. We know it is a fake foto. But the message behind this posting is all we have to think about. Offer you a lousy cooked meal doesnt mean that i can not cook. It could possible mean that you are not welcome. Post a message like that to us doesnt mean he is making any statement or the linkage of the ppl in the foto but the methaphor behind is have we ever think about the linkage of these ppl on this trial? Dont sue Chua. All these comments on this particular post just show all of us how bad the last 50 years of independent of the country has become and yet we are still so dump and fighting among ourself on various classic historical topics. Like Racism, Power over another ethnic group, Corruptions and all others.
on 11 Jul 2007 at 12:43 pm193Srimelan

Firstly …. this picture has been modified … clues
1. Table is set for two people
2. Resolution of the picture differ between DPM and others in the picture

Anyone can find this out just look at the picture.
on 11 Jul 2007 at 2:20 pm194Ary

For someone with high credentials like you Mr Tian Chua you need to get your eyes checked before posting things like this on such accesible public websites as your blog. I think that your only intention here is to create doubt among member’s of the public which does not serve for the betterment of our society anyway. So please take this out of your website or face further embarassment. Thank you.
on 11 Jul 2007 at 3:01 pm195uutjutjut

TSUN TZU’S ART OF WAR…IF YOU WANT TO MAKE THE ENEMY SOLDIERS NERVOUS…BEAT THE WAR DRUM SUDDENLY AT MIDNIGHT, THEN STOP, BEAT AGAIN AT MORNING , THEN STOP, THEN BEAT AGAIN NON STOP…BUT NO ATTACK…ONLY TO MAKE THEM FREAKED OUT, NERVOUS AND SLEEPLESS NIGHT…THE PIC OF”FRENCH DINNER” IS THE FAKE WAR DRUM… AND THE UMNO NO.2 IS NOW FREAKED OUT AND SLEEPLESS TOO…HELL BREAK LOSE IF THEY DARE TOUCH TIAN CHUA…AS THE WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING…BE AFRAID ..VERY AFRAID..AS MORE “FRENCH DINNER.”"INDIAN DINNER”"MONGOLIAN DINNER” “MALAY DINNER”…..WILL COME OUT………
on 11 Jul 2007 at 4:27 pm196bijan sijan

Guys, have a sense of humour! this is the net. this is najib and the accused’s childhood wet dream of being close to a chinese looking woman, but now it exploded in their face. barisan is corrupt, it has no legitimacy in ruling, it uses names of non registered voters in opposition areas, Najib can tell the world about this as well! Come on Najib, kawanku! Vote the opposition and bring these clowns to town! the saying goes, if you always do what you do, you will also always get what you have been getting. i dont trust those anwar clowns either but its better than voting the present corrupted in bred morons in, especially those in MCA,
on 11 Jul 2007 at 4:39 pm197wa wa wee wa

knock knock knocking on heavens door…. hello murderers . hello najib, hello corrupted politicians. hello mahatir, hello badawi. some of you have directly or indirectly been responsible for plundering the country. korea was so much poorer in the 80’s, thailand was so much further behind, even indonesia has made strides, while negaraku is left standing still, a laughing stock of the world, so bad that the eu representative to the negara has made a comment on the racist policies which are holding it back. wake up ahmad, wake up ali, this is the 21 st century, you are no sons of the soil, but the son of laughing stocks!.
on 11 Jul 2007 at 5:17 pm198manmathan

Ini gambar tipulah. Gambar nampak macam lain. Badan Najib lebih besar. Nampak pelik.

la vie existe grace aux choix

French dinner for 3

254 Responses to “French dinner for 3”